Every day, our journalism dismantles barriers and shines a light on the critical overlooked and under-reported issues important to all North Carolinians.
DA: Audit’s release would ‘jeopardize ongoing or future criminal investigations’
Both Buncombe County District Attorney Ron Moore and Blueline Systems & Services Manager Mike Wright have filed sworn statements in a pending lawsuit seeking the release of a contested Asheville Police Department’s evidence-room audit.
The affidavits, released today, both offer arguments about when and how the audit should be released. Moore’s office is named as a defendant in the suit, which was filed in June by Carolina Public Press, the Asheville Citizen-Times, Mountain Xpress, WCQS and WLOS after repeated public records requests for the report were either refused or ignored. The city of Asheville, which is also named in the suit, commissioned the study after it was discovered that guns, drugs and money were missing from the evidence room.
Wright’s statement reads, in part: “As Blueline interprets its Service Contract with the City, the City can receive a copy of the inventory report only after the District Attorney for the 28th Prosecutorial District finishes reviewing the report (which has approximately 15 volumes which range in thickness from 1 to 3 inches each) and makes redactions which, in his sole judgment, he deems necessary and proper to prevent the disclosure of information in the report from jeopardizing criminal investigations or prosecutions. … The District Attorney has not yet informed Blueline that he has finished reviewing the inventory report or that he has determined whether any information in the report can be disclosed to the City without jeopardizing criminal investigations or prosecutions.”
Moore also said, in part: “At this time, I have determined that the release of the report or any portions of it to the City would likely jeopardize one or more criminal prosecutions; undermine ongoing or future criminal investigations; and create publicity, which might prevent a Defendant from receiving a fair trial. … Public disclosure of this report or any part of it before I have had the opportunity to finish determining which portions may be released to the City and when and upon which conditions will in my opinion jeopardize ongoing or future criminal investigations and prosecutions.”
Both documents may be read in their entirety below. The case is scheduled to be heard Tuesday in Buncombe County Superior Court.Affidavit of Ronald Moore regarding the Asheville Police Department evidence-room audit lawsuit (PDF)
Affidavit of Ronald Moore regarding the Asheville Police Department evidence-room audit lawsuit (Text) Affidavit of Michael Wright regarding the Asheville Police Department evidence-room audit lawsuit (PDF)
Affidavit of Michael Wright regarding the Asheville Police Department evidence-room audit lawsuit (Text)