Journalism with impact

I want to receive independent, investigative local news every day.

A change in forest management techniques, including fire, is helping restore the once-pervasive longleaf pine in Croatan National Forest along North Carolina’s central coastal region.

The success of ongoing efforts holds promise because the trees are hardier against wildfires and extreme storms than other species.

They also are home to a diverse range of plant and animal life, some of which is unique to the region.

The venus flytrap is one of the plants native to North Carolina’s coastal forests. Jack Igelman / Carolina Public Press

Longleaf pine forest diversity

For an untrained eye, studying the understory of a longleaf pine forest in Croatan National Forest in eastern North Carolina seems unremarkable. Yet, concealed among the longleaf habitat’s low-flung grasses are dozens of strange and varied living things.

“Diversity in the herb layer is some of the highest recorded on Earth,” said Croatan National Forest botanist Andy Walker. “In the mountains the diversity is in the trees; here, it’s at your feet. This is a ballet of plants and animals in co-evolution.”

In the midst of the varied plant life is the Venus’ flytrap, one of five insect-devouring organisms in the forest. Another is Pinguicula, commonly known as butterwort, whose digestive glands line its leaf to capture prey. The otherworldly plants evolved to eat insects since there was little else to survive on in the sandy, nutrient-deprived soil of the coastal plains’ longleaf pine ecosystem.

Selling flytraps on the roadside was once a cottage industry in the Carolinas, Walker said. Despite the ongoing threat from poachers – harvesting them from federal land is now a felony – they are thriving in portions of the Croatan.

Yet to protect the flytrap and the robust array of plant and animal life, land managers throughout North Carolina’s coastal plain have made a spirited effort to restore the threatened native longleaf pine and wiregrass habitat that, in its heyday, swept across 90 million acres of the Southeastern coastal plain from Virginia to east Texas.

Now, the human defense of what remains boils down to a single ingredient: fire.

Healthy and unhealthy fire

There’s no better place to observe the longleaf forest’s revival than in Croatan National Forest. One of four national forests in North Carolina, the 160,000-acre forest south of New Bern is bordered by the Neuse and White Oak rivers and Bogue Sound on the Atlantic Ocean along its southern boundary.

Its inland landscape includes, in addition to longleaf habitat, saltwater estuaries and raised swamps known as pocosins. In all, the Forest Service estimates that 15,000 of the original 60,000 acres of longleaf have been restored in the Croatan.

For thousands of years, fires caused by lightning strikes maintained its complex ecological design. Currently, Croatan National Forest has implemented a combination of prescribed fires and other timber management techniques, such as thinnings, to re-establish healthy sections of longleaf pine habitat.

That aim is in sharp contrast to past management choices in which forest managers prioritized timber production over habitat restoration and replaced thousands of acres of longleaf with rows of more economically productive loblolly pine that foresters protected from fire.

Truth delivered daily

“This area has a history of burning, but it also has a long period where fire was excluded,” said David Nelson, Croatan National Forest fire management officer.

Without fire, he said, other species, such as oak, fast-growing loblolly pine and dense shrubs compete with the longleaf and crowd out the diversity of species and ankle-high wiregrass that help carry light, consistent burns.

Hervey McIver, the longleaf pine protection director of The Nature Conservancy in North Carolina, said that in addition to the tree’s ecological value, the longleaf has meaningful ties to North Carolina’s cultural heritage. The longleaf pines were tapped for tar and resin to waterproof ships, and its lumber was coveted for masts and furniture.

“It’s a connection to something that once was,” said McIver, who focuses on land protection in the Carolina sandhills and coastal plain regions. For perspective, McIver said that the America’s Longleaf Restoration Initiative, a public and private network of multiple organizations, has targeted a goal of increasing the longleaf habitat’s range from 3 million to 8 million acres throughout the Southeast by 2025.

History aside, McIver said, there’s a practical reason to improve the ecosystem. For one, a healthy longleaf ecosystem is a better defense against catastrophic fire than an overgrown forest where fire has been suppressed.

Out-of-control wildfire is more difficult and costly to contain. In the past, large wildfires have seared the Croatan, including the Pocosin Fire of 1955, which burned 73,000 acres, and the Fish Day Fire, which consumed 25,000 acres in 1995.

While a goal of 8 million acres may seem modest compared with the historical range of the longleaf, it’s symbolic of a drastic change of course in how forest managers and conservationists value and manage the longleaf ecology.

“When I started (with The Nature Conservancy), we would find a site, buy it and call it conserved, but we would forget about the management,” said McIver, who has worked at The Nature Conservancy since 1997, following a stint from 1980-82.

Now, conservation organizations and public agencies, including the U.S. Forest Service and the U.S. military, have implemented a regime of prescribed burning to manage and restore stands of longleaf.

Typically, a healthy longleaf forest is relatively open and roomy. Its lack of density allows a balance of sunlight and space that help nurture its uncanny diversity. But for a longleaf forest to remain open, regular fire is a must.

McIver said that currently there’s a surge of attention, funding and resources available to manage prescribed fires.

“We are sitting fat right now, but there is a concern that those sources will dry out as attention is focused elsewhere,” he said.

And as development encroaches on coastal forests, McIver worries that it may become more difficult and costly to manage the risk and impact of controlled burns, such as containing smoke, which may produce health and safety concerns in nearby communities.

According to Nelson, the Forest Service targets managed burns in a single location of the Croatan every two to five years to match the natural cycle of fire. The annual goal is to burn roughly 20,000 to 25,000 acres. Nelson said how a fire burns depends on a range of factors such as wind, humidity, topography and fuel load. A forest understory that’s too thick, for example, can stoke flames that burn longer and hotter and can damage longleaf pines or burn out precious species.

Among the species particularly sensitive to fire is the federally endangered red cockaded woodpecker, which builds cavities in mature, living pines that are 80-100 years old.

“They are an indicator species for a healthy longleaf ecosystem,” said Hugo Cobos, Croatan National Forest wildlife biologist. He said a woodpecker pecks a small cavity in a cluster of trees for its brood to roost in at night. When the family vacates, owls, squirrels, bluebirds and other creatures eventually move in. As a defense mechanism, the woodpecker flecks off the bark surrounding its roost, exposing a sticky resin that shields it from predators. The substance, however, is flammable.

“Historically, the fires didn’t reach high enough, but without managing the fire load, it’s a different story,” said Cobos. “If the understory gets too high, a wildfire will burn them out.”

Residents of the Croatan National Forest include some who are well-adapted to blend in. Jack Igelman / Carolina Public Press

Broader benefits of healthy longleaf pine forest

While a regime of fire may benefit specific species, returning the threatened ecosystem to health has practical benefits at a broader landscape level, too. A healthy, functioning ecosystem, Cobos said, is more adaptable to a changing environment.

Become a Carolina Public Press insider.

Text INSIDER to (919)897-8555 and be among the first to hear about special events and exclusive content.

For instance, the longleaf treescape is relatively more resilient to extreme storms that may be more common in the future as a result of climate change. Mature longleaf trees have a uniform height and a deep root system that increases their tolerance to damage from heavy winds typical in hurricane country.

Of course, the trees are just a part of the equation. After all, in a forest dominated by a single tree species, the real party is on the ground, where a medley of species flourishes under the right conditions.

“Open habitats have incredible diversity. The plants and trees around us are the result of many thousands of years of natural selection in which the primary driver was fire,” said Walker. “This didn’t just pop up overnight.”


Support independent, in-depth and investigative news for all of North Carolina

Carolina Public Press is transforming from a regionally focused nonprofit news organization to the go-to independent, in-depth and investigative news arm for North Carolina. Your are critical to this transformation — and the future of investigative reporting for all North Carolinians.

Unlike many others, we aren’t owned by umbrella organizations or corporations. And we haven’t put up a paywall — we believe that fact-based, context-rich watchdog journalism is a vital public service. But we need to ask for your help. Carolina Public Press’s in-depth, investigative journalism takes a lot of money, dedication and hard work to produce. We are here because we believe in and are dedicated to the future of North Carolina.

So, if you believe in this, too, please take a moment to make a tax-deductible contribution. Your gift could be DOUBLED right now. It only takes a minute. Thank you!

Jack Igelman

Jack Igelman is a contributing reporter with Carolina Public Press. Contact him at jack@igelman.com.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *